• Madison Rayne Jacobs made his debut for Insanity Pro Wrestling in Indianapolis, Indiana on August 1, 2009 at Reign Of The Insane Stage 1 in a losing effort to local wrestler Aaron Williams.  • Daga  • El Generico e Kevin Steen In an interview with a German website, Jacobs revealed there would be more people involved. The Irish Airborne (David and Jake Crist) entered the ring to save Jack Evans, which led to a six-man tag team match between The Age of the Fall and the team of Evans and the Irish Airborne.  • Kevin Steen e El Generico Since joining the Cleveland based promotion, Jacobs won the Prime Wrestling Heavyweight Championship from Matt Cross, only to lose it shortly after to a returning Gargano.

 • Jake Crist [4] After graduating, he attended college for three years before deciding to focus on his wrestling career as a full-time job in May 2005.
Afterwards, over a dozen men dressed in black clothing and black masks climbed into the cage and attacked Black, while Jacobs proclaimed that the Age of the Fall was not over. Il rejoint la fédération en tant que producteur.  • ReDRagon (Bobby Fish e Kyle O'Reilly) [19] They also managed Edwin Rosario, who became a three time world lightweight champion, and 1970s middleweight contender Eugene Hart.  • Rich Swann Whitmer. He was previously signed to the American professional wrestling promotion All Elite Wrestling (AEW). The following night, after Kenta had defeated Black, Jacobs and his followers attacked Black again and tried to hang him upside down above the ring, but were stopped by Kevin Steen, El Generico and Delirious.  • Guerrillas of Destiny (Tama Tonga e Tanga Loa) On June 5, 2010 at Desperate Measures Jacobs would go on to defeat Drake Younger. On December 14, 2013, at Final Battle 2013, Jacobs turned heel again, alongside BJ Whitmer and Roderick Strong; the trio attacked Eddie Edwards, explaining they were sick of people being celebrated for leaving the company, while the constant wrestlers in ROH went unappreciated. [16] On June 23, 2013, S.C.U.M. On March 30, 2008, Aries left the ring with Lacey, who was going to 'convince' him, and it was implied that the two had sex. Jacobs would go on to make his third music video (in which he has been described as being "demented") expressing his feelings on her disfigurement. Post match Jacobs called out Aries and the two brawled, before Aries was attacked Black, Matthews and Gowen.  • Su Yung It later progressed when Daizee Haze joined forces with Whitmer, and Lacey, in turn as the leader of the group, hired an "assassin", Mercedes Martinez. The newly formed group went under the name of "The Decade". While Jacobs was injured, ROH decided to continue the Lacey-Jacobs storyline with 4 small vignettes shown on YouTube, detailing a trip that Lacey spent in Chicago with Jacobs; afterward, he accompanied Lacey to the ring for her matches, in which they appeared to have swapped personalities. The two continued to wrestle several minutes longer. Cabana left the team because he was annoyed at Lacey, and tried to explain to Jacobs that she was using him. Jacobs made his first appearance for World Wrestling Entertainment (WWE) in May 2005, when he won a match against Eddie Guerrero via disqualification on SmackDown!.

[22] On August 21, 2010 at IPW 9th Anniversary Reign Of The Insane, Jacobs challenged Moxley for the IPW World Heavyweight Championship in a losing effort.